(dbeckler)
Maybe I need to be more specific because I know that David is better too. But does anyone actually know their ranges?
Did you get an answer to your original question yet???
Archive » David vs. Josh/Newman
by Linda B. » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 7:40 pm
Did you get an answer to your original question yet???
- Linda B.
by OKBill » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 7:09 pm
Be that as it may, let me say this about that. I just can't imagine how anybody can equal David in even this one offbeat, unintended category: when people make bootleg recordings at live concerts with low fidelity mini microphones and then post them on bandwidth limited YouTube etc, Davids singing even cuts through all of the distortion and garbage introduced into the vocal track! I just don't know anyone else that can do that. :?:
Even in that bloopers video where he talks awhile then shouts CALLIE PUT THOSE SCISSORS DOWN or whatever, his YELLING is in that peerless full voice high tenor!!!
Even in that bloopers video where he talks awhile then shouts CALLIE PUT THOSE SCISSORS DOWN or whatever, his YELLING is in that peerless full voice high tenor!!!
- OKBill
by leeg22 » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 6:56 pm
I do apologize... In my opinion... I agree that they both have good voices, but I just simply like David's better... Thanks for giving your's Janette... We all have good taste in music, I think... we're talking about the very best in both fields.
Pals can agree and disagree on anything... That's what makes life interesting...
Hugs,
Lee
Pals can agree and disagree on anything... That's what makes life interesting...
Hugs,
Lee
- leeg22
by Janette » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 5:58 pm
(leeg22)
David's voice overall is way stronger. I think he is better trained, but in a different way. David has learned to transition from his upper range to his lower range and back without breaks in the tone. He can fully do 3 octaves
with power when needed at both ends of the spectrum.
I think Josh's range is limited. I can't recall him really popping any high or low range songs. He is not a true tenor, but he sings middle range songs to not emphasize his limits. I liked his voice for a while, but got tired of the sameness of all his music. I don't recall any really strong up tunes either... He loves ballads and "big" numbers..but they all start to sound the same after a while.
That's another reason why I know I love David's voice. He is more versatile, I think... He does a variety of styles and does an up tune better than anyone...but he can't be compared to a living soul with his ballads.
David also has God leading him and it shows with every project he does or every performance he puts out there.
Haven't thought about this in a while... Thanks,
Lee
This is one of those threads that every post should start with "in my opinion"...My love of dp's voice is just as much as anyones...I can't say, in my opinion, that dp is "way" stronger, he just uses it differently. As far as the sameness in Josh's music, I have all of his cd/dvd's (as I do with dp) and there is quite a selection of different music...and as far as ballads go...I could listen to them all day..not much into the up beat type of songs from any performer, but that is my personal preference...this is dp's board and I know I am in a minority...I just think they both have wonderful God given talents...they shouldn't be compared, again...just my opinion!.with power when needed at both ends of the spectrum.
I think Josh's range is limited. I can't recall him really popping any high or low range songs. He is not a true tenor, but he sings middle range songs to not emphasize his limits. I liked his voice for a while, but got tired of the sameness of all his music. I don't recall any really strong up tunes either... He loves ballads and "big" numbers..but they all start to sound the same after a while.
That's another reason why I know I love David's voice. He is more versatile, I think... He does a variety of styles and does an up tune better than anyone...but he can't be compared to a living soul with his ballads.
David also has God leading him and it shows with every project he does or every performance he puts out there.
Haven't thought about this in a while... Thanks,
Lee
- Janette
by leeg22 » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 5:44 pm
David's voice overall is way stronger. I think he is better trained, but in a different way. David has learned to transition from his upper range to his lower range and back without breaks in the tone. He can fully do 3 octaves
with power when needed at both ends of the spectrum.
I think Josh's range is limited. I can't recall him really popping any high or low range songs. He is not a true tenor, but he sings middle range songs to not emphasize his limits. I liked his voice for a while, but got tired of the sameness of all his music. I don't recall any really strong up tunes either... He loves ballads and "big" numbers..but they all start to sound the same after a while.
That's another reason why I know I love David's voice. He is more versatile, I think... He does a variety of styles and does an up tune better than anyone...but he can't be compared to a living soul with his ballads.
David also has God leading him and it shows with every project he does or every performance he puts out there.
Haven't thought about this in a while... Thanks,
Lee
with power when needed at both ends of the spectrum.
I think Josh's range is limited. I can't recall him really popping any high or low range songs. He is not a true tenor, but he sings middle range songs to not emphasize his limits. I liked his voice for a while, but got tired of the sameness of all his music. I don't recall any really strong up tunes either... He loves ballads and "big" numbers..but they all start to sound the same after a while.
That's another reason why I know I love David's voice. He is more versatile, I think... He does a variety of styles and does an up tune better than anyone...but he can't be compared to a living soul with his ballads.
David also has God leading him and it shows with every project he does or every performance he puts out there.
Haven't thought about this in a while... Thanks,
Lee
- leeg22
by Janette » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 5:23 pm
(LoveGoesOn)
(Janette)
James...I wouldn't compare that particular song!! Pick another one!
Ummm, I can't think of anything right off hand - that's the only song that they BOTH have recorded. Any suggestions?
James
- Janette
by TheStarSailor » Tue Jun 5, 2007 pm30 5:20 pm
(Janette)
James...I wouldn't compare that particular song!! Pick another one!
Ummm, I can't think of anything right off hand - that's the only song that they BOTH have recorded. Any suggestions?
James
- TheStarSailor